All News

Navigating Mortgage Challenges: Strategies and Legal Shifts in Real Estate Market

Facing historic affordability challenges, buyers turn to creative mortgage strategies amid rising rates and a landmark NAR settlement reshaping commissions.

By Mackenzie Crow

4/4, 07:48 EDT

Key Takeaway

  • Mortgage rates hit 6.9%, with forecasts predicting an average of 6.1% by Q4, amid high home prices and market volatility.
  • Buyers and sellers adopt creative strategies like temporary buydowns, permanent buydowns, and mortgage assumptions to manage costs.
  • A $418 million NAR settlement will change commission negotiations, potentially lowering rates and saving money for buyers/sellers.

Mortgage Affordability Challenges Persist

The current real estate market presents significant affordability challenges for prospective home buyers, with single-family homes reaching their highest expense level in over three decades. This trend is driven by historically high home prices coupled with elevated mortgage rates, a situation unlikely to see immediate relief. Joel Kan, deputy chief economist of the Mortgage Bankers Association, forecasts an average mortgage rate of 6.1% by the fourth quarter of this year, amidst expectations of market volatility influenced by consumer spending and inflation data. Recent weeks have seen a slight uptick in mortgage rates, with Freddie Mac reporting a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage at 6.9%, an increase from 6.65% in mid-February but below the peak of 7.79% in October.

Innovative Mortgage Strategies

In response to these challenges, buyers and sellers are exploring creative mortgage arrangements to alleviate financial pressures. One such strategy is the temporary buydown, where sellers or builders pay an upfront fee to reduce the buyer's mortgage rate for a specified period. This approach has gained popularity as mortgage rates climbed, offering buyers temporary relief with the expectation of personal income growth. Another method is the permanent buydown, allowing buyers to reduce their mortgage payments for the loan's life by purchasing prepaid interest points at closing. This option offers long-term savings but requires a significant upfront investment. Mortgage assumptions present a third alternative, enabling buyers to assume the seller's existing mortgage, potentially at a lower interest rate, though this option is limited to certain government-backed or insured loans.

Legal and Market Shifts

The real estate industry is also navigating significant legal and market shifts that could impact commission structures and the home buying process. A landmark $418 million settlement with the National Association of Realtors (NAR) will change how agent commissions are negotiated and could lead to a reduction in commission rates. This settlement arises from claims that the industry conspired to keep commissions artificially high. Starting in mid-July, home listings will no longer need to include upfront offers to buyers' agents, allowing buyers to negotiate compensation directly. This change is expected to make the commission process more transparent and could save both buyers and sellers thousands of dollars.

Street Views

  • Joel Kan, Mortgage Bankers Association (Neutral on mortgage rates):

    "We predict mortgage rates to average 6.1% by the fourth quarter of this year."

  • Greg McBride, Bankrate (Neutral on temporary buydowns):

    "It can give a buyer time to ease into higher payments if they expect their personal income will rise in the months ahead."

  • Brian Nevins, Bay Equity Home Loans (Bullish on temporary buydowns):

    "If rates drop before the temporary buydown funds are depleted, they can use the balance in the account to pay down their mortgage."

  • Kate Amor, Guaranteed Rate (Neutral on buydown eligibility and restrictions):

    "Buydowns can’t be used on the purchase of an investment property or in a cash-out refinancing."

  • Bill Banfield, Rocket Cos. (Neutral on permanent buydowns):

    "If you plan on taking a long-term fixed-rate loan that isn't going to be refinanced soon, these can make sense."

  • Shant Banosian, Guaranteed Rate (Cautiously Optimistic about buying discount points for permanent rate reduction):

    "It typically takes 5 to 6 years to break even on the upfront cost of a buydown."